9626 · AS TOPIC 1.4 · 2025–2027
Validation vs verification
A value can pass every input rule and still be wrong. Follow the difference from a source document to a stored record.
By Abdurrahman Tolay · Updated
Two different questions
Validation asks: does this value meet the rules? Verification asks: does this entry match its source or survive a defined accuracy check? Both can improve data quality. Neither guarantees that the original fact is true.
In the 9626 syllabus, AS topic 1.4 is ‘Checking the accuracy of data’. It includes input validation and verification, their differences and limitations. A2 learners should retain these AS foundations.
Worked example: the registration form
A club accepts ages from 11 to 18 inclusive. Sam's paper form says 16. The operator enters 17.
- A presence check passes because the age field is not blank.
- A type check passes because the entry is numeric.
- A range check passes because 17 is between 11 and 18.
- Visual checking against the form can detect that 17 differs from 16.
Validation accepted a plausible value, not the correct value. Double data entry can also flag a difference if a second independent entry is 16, but two identical incorrect entries can still match.
Match a rule to a requirement
- Presence: required fields must contain a value. It does not show that the value is meaningful.
- Range or limit: values must meet specified numeric boundaries. Test both accepted boundary values and values just outside them.
- Length and format: an identifier may require a defined length and pattern. A code with the right shape can still belong to the wrong person.
- Lookup: a value must be in an approved set. A valid choice can still be the wrong choice for the record.
- Consistency: related entries must agree with a defined relationship, for example an end date must not precede a start date.
The syllabus also includes check digits. A check digit is calculated from other digits using a specified method to help detect entry errors; it is not encryption and cannot detect every possible error.
Verification goes beyond double entry
Visual checking compares an entry with the source; double data entry compares two entries. Topic 1.4 also includes parity checks, checksums, hash totals and control totals. These checks can help detect data changes or transmission/processing errors under their particular rules. They do not verify whether a person's stated age is true.
Keep the explanation tied to the method. A matching checksum is not evidence that a source document was accurate, and visual verification depends on careful comparison.
Boundary tests make rules visible
For ages 11–18 inclusive, test 10 (reject), 11 (accept), 18 (accept) and 19 (reject). Test a blank entry and text separately. These examples test the rules; compare a plausible entered age with the original form to test transcription.
Common mistakes
- Writing ‘validation makes data accurate’ without considering plausible wrong values.
- Using a presence check when the requirement specifies a numeric interval.
- Claiming matching double entry proves the source fact is true.
- Confusing a format check with a source comparison.
Try it: valid, verified or true?
An ID must contain six digits. The source shows 042681. Both operators enter 042681, but the source itself belongs to another member. Which checks pass, and what remains unresolved?
Model explanation
Length and numeric-format checks pass. Double entry matches, and visual checking against that source also matches. The record is still associated with the wrong member. Source identity must be resolved separately: validation and verification do not establish the truth of the underlying source. This is an original learning answer, not an official mark scheme.
Keep the learning connected.
Syllabus placement: 9626 AS topic 1.4, Checking the accuracy of data, printed p. 15.
Sources and scope
- Cambridge AS & A Level IT 9626 syllabus, 2025–2027, version 3
- Official past papers and specimen materials
Independent original learning resources, not affiliated with or endorsed by Cambridge International. Check the syllabus and entry route for your exam year with your school. 9626 resources here cover 2025–2027, not the different 2028–2030 syllabus.
